In a hot, arid climate the greenhouse has to lose heat for most of the year. The practical way to do that at scale is to evaporate water into the air. Pad-and-fan and semi-closed greenhouses both rely on this effect, but they apply it differently, and the difference shows in crop uniformity, water use and investment.
Start with wet-bulb temperature
Evaporative cooling cannot bring air below its wet-bulb temperature, the temperature air reaches when it is saturated with water. Dry air has a wet-bulb temperature far below its measured (dry-bulb) temperature; humid air does not. This is why the first document we ask for is hourly climate data for the site, not the record high.
A typical evaporative pad works at 75–85% efficiency. On an afternoon of 42 °C with a wet-bulb temperature of 22 °C, air leaves the pad at roughly 25–27 °C. On a humid afternoon of 38 °C with a wet-bulb temperature of 30 °C, the same pad delivers air at about 31–32 °C, which is too warm for most crops.
How pad-and-fan works
Wet cellulose pads fill one wall of the greenhouse and extraction fans fill the opposite wall. The fans pull outside air through the pads and along the length of the house. The system is simple, proven and comparatively inexpensive.
Its limits are well known:
- Air warms as it travels, so there is a temperature gradient from pad to fan, typically 4–7 °C over 40 metres.
- That gradient limits the pad-to-fan distance, typically to 40–50 metres, which shapes the whole site layout.
- The house runs under slight negative pressure, so every gap draws in unfiltered air, dust and insects.
- Vents stay closed while the fans run, and most of the CO₂ supplied to the crop leaves with the exhaust air.
How a semi-closed greenhouse works
In a semi-closed greenhouse, air is prepared in a corridor along the end wall. Outside air passes through pads, is mixed with recirculated greenhouse air as needed and is blown by fans into perforated ducts under the growing gutters. Conditioned air rises through the crop and leaves through a small number of roof vents.
The greenhouse runs under slight overpressure. Insects and dust are kept out, the climate is more even along the row and CO₂ stays in the house for longer. Because air treatment is concentrated in one place, chilled-water coils or dehumidification can be added there for humid periods. The price is a higher investment, more fan power and a more demanding control strategy.
Side by side
| Criterion | Pad-and-fan | Semi-closed |
|---|---|---|
| Investment | Lower | Higher |
| Temperature uniformity | Gradient from pad to fan | Even along the row |
| Pressure in the house | Negative | Positive |
| Insect and dust exclusion | Depends on sealing | Good |
| CO₂ enrichment | Mostly lost | Largely retained |
| Humid periods | Little effect | Mechanical cooling can be added |
| Typical use | Dry inland sites, moderate budgets | High-value crops, year-round supply, coastal sites |
Do not forget the water
Evaporative cooling consumes water, and in a desert climate that water is often desalinated. On the hottest days the cooling system can use as much water as the crop. Pad water also concentrates salts as it evaporates, so part of it has to be bled off to protect the pads from scaling. We include cooling in the water balance from the first calculation and, where mechanical cooling is installed, recover its condensate.
How to choose
- Count the humid hours. If the summer wet-bulb temperature rarely rises above the low twenties, evaporative cooling alone is usually enough for fruiting vegetables.
- Look at the crop. Lettuce and berries tolerate less heat than tomato or cucumber.
- Decide on the calendar. A summer break of six to eight weeks removes the most expensive cooling hours. Year-round supply contracts do not allow one.
- Price the water and the electricity. They decide the operating cost of either system.
The right cooling system is the one sized for your worst humid week, not for your hottest dry day.
We compare both options against the site’s climate file during the feasibility study, and we show the result as the number of hours per year in which the crop would be outside its target range.
